The Art of Auditioning for a Theatrical Production

Auditioning is one of the most vital — and often most nerve-wracking — parts of a theatrical production. For actors, it’s the moment of truth: a brief window of opportunity to convince a director that they are the perfect fit for a role. For directors, auditions are a careful balancing act of instinct, evaluation, and decision-making — the process of discovery as they search for performers who can bring the characters to life.

Though auditions can be daunting, they also represent the essence of theatre: collaboration, risk, and the exhilarating act of transformation. Understanding the process from both the actor’s and the director’s perspectives — and finding ways to make that process comfortable and humane — can lead to better performances, better casting choices, and ultimately, better theatre.

My name’s Peter Fernandez, and in this article, I’m going to be taking a look at what it means to both attend and hold an audition, as part of the process of creating a theatrical show.

The Purpose of an Audition

At its simplest, an audition is a meeting between possibility and opportunity. The actor offers a glimpse of their interpretation of a character, while the director seeks to see how that interpretation aligns with their vision for the production. But the deeper purpose is not merely to test or judge — it is to explore potential; in this sense, an audition is less about proving oneself and more about finding the right artistic match.

Auditions reveal not only talent but also adaptability, professionalism, and chemistry. Directors are not just asking, “Can this person play the role?” but also, “Can we work well together for the next several months?” Similarly, actors are gauging whether this production feels like the right creative fit for them; reaffirming why they endure the uncertainty — the thrill of connection, the joy of storytelling, and the hope of collaboration.

When viewed from the right perspective, auditions are not adversarial but collaborative. Both actors and directors are artists seeking to tell a story together. In the best auditions, there is a sense of shared discovery: the moment an actor brings something unexpected — a fresh reading, a surprising emotion — that illuminates a new aspect of the character. In that instant, the audition transcends evaluation and becomes creation:

It demands courage from actors and compassion from directors; it’s an encounter where two creative visions meet, test each other, and sometimes merge into something extraordinary.

“You know it when it happens. The room shifts. The actor finishes, and everyone feels the energy in the room change. You’ve just seen your character come to life.”

When both sides approach auditions not as judgment but as dialogue, the process becomes transformative. Directors discover talent they might never have expected. Actors find roles that challenge and fulfil them.

In the end, every audition — successful or not — is part of the larger journey of theatre. Each one is a rehearsal for the next opportunity, a chance to grow, and a reminder that behind every casting decision lies a shared love of storytelling.

The Emotional Landscape of Auditioning

Auditions are emotionally charged spaces. For actors, vulnerability is their greatest tool…and their greatest challenge. Opening oneself up to be judged artistically can feel deeply personal.

For directors, auditions are a dance between objectivity and empathy. They must balance their artistic vision with the humanity of those auditioning. Both sides experience nerves, pressure, and anticipation.

Creating an atmosphere of mutual respect transforms auditions from tests into creative exchanges. When an actor feels seen and supported, their performance becomes more authentic. When a director feels trust from the actors, their casting decisions become more inspired.

Preparing for an Audition

For an actor, preparation is the foundation of confidence. Whether it’s a community theatre play or a professional musical, success begins long before stepping into the audition room.

Understanding the Material

Actors typically start by researching the play or musical they are auditioning for. Reading the full script — if available — is essential to understanding not only one’s desired role but also the tone and themes of the piece. Context matters: knowing how a character fits into the larger story allows an actor to make informed, dynamic choices.

In some cases, actors may only have access to audition “sides” (short excerpts of the script provided for performance). Even then, exploring the character’s motivations, relationships, and circumstances can set one performance apart from the rest.

Rehearsing the Material

When auditioning for musicals, performers are often asked to prepare a song that suits the style of the show — something that showcases their range and personality without mimicking the score too directly. For plays, they may be asked to perform a monologue or a cold reading (as in performing material they’ve just been given). Whichever, the key is to choose material that feels authentic:

“Pick something that fits you like a glove — not like a costume you’re trying to squeeze into.”

Managing Nerves and Expectations

Even the most experienced performers get nervous. The challenge is not to eliminate nerves but to channel them productively. Simple rituals — deep breathing, stretching, or quiet mental focus — can calm anxiety before stepping into the audition room.

Remember, an audition is not a test per se, but a collaboration-in-progress; the goal is not perfection, but honesty. A director is not looking for a finished performance; they’re looking for those sparks of truth and imagination.

Creating a Comfortable and Respectful Audition Environment

Both directors and actors share a common goal — namely, a productive, positive audition process — and small details can make a big difference in setting a welcoming tone and encouraging authentic performances.

For Actors

• Professional Courtesy:
  Arrive early, prepared, and polite. Treat audition staff and other actors with kindness (word travels quickly in theatre circles).
• Adaptability:
  Directors may ask for adjustments or unexpected readings. Treat these as opportunities to collaborate, not as criticism.
• Self-Compassion:
  Not getting a role doesn’t mean failure. Casting is complex, and sometimes the decision has little to do with talent.
• Feedback and Growth:
  Reflect on each audition experience as a learning opportunity. Every room entered, every line read, refines one’s craft.

For Directors and Production Teams

• Clarity and Communication:
  Provide clear information about what’s expected — materials to prepare, time slots, attire, and format. Ambiguity breeds anxiety.
• Warmth and Professionalism:
  A friendly greeting, a smile, or a quick introduction helps actors relax. Directors set the emotional tone of the room.
• Respecting Time:
  Staying on schedule shows respect for actors’ commitment, particularly those balancing day jobs or travel.
• Constructive Redirection:
  When giving adjustments, phrase them positively: “Try this with more urgency,” rather than “That wasn’t right.” Directors should empower, not intimidate.
• Inclusivity and Accessibility:
  Consider diverse casting, accessible venues, and sensitivity to disabilities or cultural contexts. The theatre community thrives when everyone feels welcome.

Inside the Audition Room

Walking into an audition room can feel like stepping into another world—a mix of anticipation, adrenaline, and vulnerability. The room might be bare, with just a table and a piano, in addition to the audition panel.

The audition panel is the team of folks you’ll be auditioning for. Typically, an audition panel will include the Director — as well as the Musical Director and the Choreographer (at least for musicals) — and may also include the Stage Manager and/or the Producer.

Making a First Impression

The first few moments matter. A warm, confident greeting can set the tone. The actor’s demeanour — poised but approachable — often speaks as loudly as their performance.

Once the audition begins, actors must balance preparation with spontaneity; Directors value bold choices but also flexibility. An actor who can take direction on the spot — adjusting tone, tempo, or emotional intent — is demonstrating not only talent but teachability.

Handling Mistakes

Every actor dreads forgetting a line or cracking a note, but directors understand that auditions are pressure-filled environments. What matters most is recovery. Maintaining composure and continuing gracefully often leaves a stronger impression than a flawless but rigid performance:

“I blanked halfway through my monologue. I smiled, took a breath, and said, ‘May I start again?’ The Director nodded. When I finished, he said, ‘That was exactly the resilience I want to see in rehearsal,’ and it taught me a lot about what matters in an audition.”

---

In the first of a two-part series, here’s Juel Brown sharing her thoughts regarding the auditions, so before we move on, feel free to take a moment and watch Juel give her take on the various aspects of the audition process:

---

Casting as Creative Curation

From the Director’s side of the table, auditions are both exhilarating and exhausting. Over a few hours — or several days — they may see dozens or even hundreds of hopefuls, each bringing their own energy, interpretation, and possibility.

Defining the Vision

Before auditions begin, a director must establish a clear vision of the production: its tone, style, and desired dynamic among characters. They might collaborate with the design team and producers to determine the type of actors needed — not just by physicality or vocal range, but by presence and temperament.

The director’s responsibility is not to find “the best” actor in absolute terms, but rather the right actor for the role and for the ensemble. Sometimes, the most technically skilled performer may not fit the overall balance or chemistry of the cast.

Observing Beyond the Performance

While actors focus on delivering their prepared material, directors are observing everything: how the actor enters the room, listens, reacts, and interacts with others during group callbacks:

“I’m looking for generosity. Does this actor make choices that serve the story, or only themselves? Are they present and adaptable? Talent is essential, but collaboration is what makes a production thrive.”

The Weight of Decision-Making

Casting decisions can be emotionally taxing. For every role filled, several talented individuals are turned away. Directors must balance empathy with practicality, knowing that rejection is an inevitable — though painful — part of the process. Professionalism, fairness, and transparency are crucial. Many directors take care to communicate audition results respectfully, understanding the vulnerability actors bring into the room.

Types of Auditions

There is no single “correct” way to hold auditions. The method chosen depends on the production’s needs, scale, and resources. Each approach has its own strengths and challenges.

Open (General) Auditions

These are accessible to anyone and are often used by community theatres or educational institutions; they often involve prepared monologues, songs, or cold readings. Open auditions emphasise inclusivity and discovery — sometimes unearthing hidden talent that formal casting calls might overlook.

• Pros: Welcomes new faces; encourages community participation.
• Cons: Time-consuming; may yield inconsistent quality.

Invited Auditions

Professional theatres or casting agencies often use this method to narrow the field. Only selected performers are invited based on résumés, headshots, or past work.

• Pros: Efficient; ensures all candidates meet baseline standards.
• Cons: Can limit diversity and exclude emerging talent.

Workshop or Improvisational Auditions

Some directors prefer a more collaborative format — asking actors to improvise scenes, devise short moments, or participate in group exercises. This approach reveals creativity, teamwork, and responsiveness.

• Pros: Shows adaptability and group dynamics.
• Cons: May disadvantage actors less comfortable with improvisation.

Video/Virtual Auditions

With technology increasingly central to casting, many productions now accept self-tapes or live video auditions. This allows broader participation, especially for touring or remote opportunities, though actors should treat these with the same professionalism as in-person auditions: clear lighting, sound quality, and genuine engagement with the material are vital.

Callbacks

Callbacks are second-round auditions where shortlisted actors read scenes together or perform additional material — where directors assess things like chemistry, range, and versatility. Callbacks and can feel more relaxed, as both sides now have context; it’s less about proving oneself and more about exploring how the ensemble fits together.

When an actor receives a callback, it signifies that something in their performance resonated. At this stage, the director often experiments with pairings — testing romantic chemistry, comedic timing, or ensemble balance.

Callbacks may involve reading full scenes, singing harmonies, or performing choreography. Directors may also use this phase to assess stamina, emotional depth, and how actors respond to notes under pressure.

Actors should view callbacks not as “round two of the competition,” but as an opportunity to collaborate — to play, explore, and engage. The director is now envisioning the show’s world in real time, and the actor is part of that discovery.

Patience; Perspective; Professionalism

Once the audition ends, the waiting begins — a difficult but crucial part of the process.

For Directors

Directors should strive for timely communication and transparency when possible. Even a simple acknowledgement — “Thank you for auditioning; casting decisions will be posted on this date” — goes a long way in respecting actors’ time and emotional investment.

For Actors

After giving their all, actors must practice patience and self-kindness. Obsessing over results rarely serves creative health. It’s important to remember that casting decisions depend on myriad factors — ensemble balance, vocal range, physical contrast, or logistical considerations — that have little to do with one’s individual ability.

Following up with a polite email thanking the director or stage manager is appropriate in professional contexts but should never be pushy. Maintaining professionalism ensures lasting respect, even if the current audition doesn’t lead to a role.

---

In the second of her two-part series, here’s Juel Brown sharing the rest of her thoughts regarding the audition: